China jails quake death activist
A Chinese activist who investigated the deaths of thousands of children crushed in their schools during the Sichuan earthquake has been sentenced to five years prison, underscoring the government’s determination to suppress questions about why the buildings fell.
Many have asked whether poor construction was responsible for the staggering number of children killed in the May 2008 temblor, which took 90,000 lives.
Parents have protested frequently and authorities have reacted severely to such demonstrations, jailing, harassing and threatening participants.
The United States quickly condemned Tuesday’s conviction of Tan Zuoren, and a human rights activist said the case was the latest example of how China uses its vague subversion laws to silence dissent.
Tan, 56, was convicted of inciting subversion of state power and handed the maximum sentence of five years’ jail by the Chengdu Intermediate Court in southwestern China’s Sichuan province, his lawyer Pu Zhiqiang said.
Tan and others have raised the possibility that shoddy construction – possibly fostered by corrupt officials who failed to enforce building codes – caused some schools to collapse in the quake while buildings nearby remained intact.
The government was widely praised for its response to the quake, which came just months before it was set to host the Olympic Games in Beijing, a time of intense scrutiny from the outside world. Authorities were eager to keep the focus on their massive rescue and relocation efforts and moved quickly to quash the politically sensitive theory.
Since then, they have kept up their campaign to silence those who pressed the issue – many of whom are parents who lost their only children. Protesters have been detained, harassed and threatened by police and thugs thought to be paid by officials.
For months after the May 12 temblor, China refused to provide an estimate of how many children had been killed in schools, prompting Tan to start his own investigation in December of that year. He hoped to have a figure before the first anniversary of the quake but was detained in March 2009. His initial estimate was that at least 5,600 students were among the dead.
The government finally announced its own official figure in May last year, saying that 5,335 students were believed to have perished in classrooms.
The court’s ruling against Tan makes no mention of his quake research, but his supporters and human rights groups say they believe he was targeted because of the project.
The court found Tan guilty of inciting subversion for drawing attention to the deadly 1989 military crackdown on pro-democracy demonstrations in Beijing’s Tiananmen Square, Pu said. The ruling cited an essay written by Tan in 2007 about the protests and a 2008 blood drive he helped organised to commemorate the demonstrations, which are also extremely sensitive in China.
“The Chinese government doesn’t seem to understand that criticism is not the same thing as incitement, and that criticism of individual officials or government agencies is not the same thing as calling for the overthrow of the government,” said Joshua Rosenzweig, research manager for the US-based Dui Hua Foundation.
“This law is being used in a quite arbitrary and irresponsible way, simply as a tool to silence opinions that the government doesn’t want to hear.”
Lu Shihua, father of a 16-year-old girl who died in the collapsed Beichuan Middle School, said Tan was “a man with a sense of justice” and added that he thought the court’s ruling was “quite extreme.”
Tan was brought to trial in August, when he pleaded not guilty in a three-hour session, while police detained and threatened supporters who came to Chengdu to witness the proceedings. The case was adjourned with no ruling until Tuesday, when similar strong-arm tactics were employed.
Chinese police officers blocked nine Hong Kong journalists from interviewing Pu outside the courthouse, Hong Kong’s radio RTHK said. The reporters were led to a room inside the courthouse and released after the verdict was announced.
An officer from the US Consulate General in Chengdu was at the courthouse for Tan’s sentencing but was not allowed in, said US Embassy spokeswoman Susan Stevenson.
“Persecution of individuals for the peaceful expression of political views is inconsistent with internationally recognised norms of human rights. The United States condemns these convictions,” Stevenson said.
Lu, who lost his daughter, said he and other parents were still waiting for the government to properly investigate the school collapses.
“What happened on that day is still in front of our eyes,” Lu said. “The cruelty and the enormous bloodshed.”